Brenda Morgan
“Amazing Team! Outstanding Service! Fair Price! Fast Booking! A New Leaf Painting brought color into my life after years of white and beige walls! Thomas, the owner, met me at my home to give me an estimate. I wanted the…”
Service area · Clay County
Bringing Lasting Beauty to Every Home
Refresh your interior. Protect your exterior. Professional painting, stucco repair, and wood rot repair for Fleming Island homes, from Eagle Harbor to Fleming Island Plantation.
700+ ReviewsSince 2010Google Verified
Prefer to talk? 904-615-6599. Office Mon to Sun, 7am to 7pm.

Exterior repaint in Eagle Harbor, Fleming Island
The A New Leaf Difference
Careful preparation, protected spaces, and clear communication—so you feel confident from the first estimate to the final walkthrough.

Local Painting & Home Improvement Services
Fleming Island homes range from newer construction in master-planned communities to established properties that have weathered years of Florida sun, humidity, and seasonal moisture. Many sit within HOA communities like Eagle Harbor, where well-kept streetscapes and ARB color approvals influence how each home is maintained and presented. Along Doctors Lake and the St. Johns River, added moisture, morning dew, and humidity can put even more stress on exterior surfaces.
Those conditions shape what each home needs. Newer homes may be approaching their first full repaint as builder-grade coatings begin to chalk and fade, while older stucco homes can develop hairline cracks, staining, failing caulk, and other signs of wear. Siding, trim, and fascia—especially on shaded or water-facing elevations—can also be more vulnerable to moisture-related deterioration.
A New Leaf Painting Contractors has completed projects throughout Fleming Island, including Eagle Harbor. We plan each project around the home’s age, surfaces, exposure, and community requirements so the finished result fits the neighborhood and performs well in the local environment.

Interior walls and ceilings, trim, and any drywall patching.
Explore Interior Painting
Coatings built for Florida sun, humidity, and lakeside moisture.
Recent job: Exterior House Painting in Eagle Harbor, Fleming Island, FLExplore Exterior Painting
A fresh kitchen or bath without the remodel bill.
Explore Cabinet Painting
Offices, storefronts and shared spaces, scheduled around your business.
Explore Commercial Painting
A hard-wearing, easy-to-clean floor for the garage.
Explore Garage Floor Coatings
Hairline cracks, delamination and water damage repaired before the paint goes on.
Recent job: Exterior House Painting in Eagle Harbor, Fleming Island, FLExplore Stucco Repair
Soft fascia, trim and siding rebuilt, so the new paint has something sound to hold.
Recent job: Fleming Island Residential Exterior RepaintExplore Wood Rot Repair
Cracks, holes and water damage patched and textured to match the wall around them.
Explore Drywall Repair
Touch-ups, a single room or a punch list, without waiting for a big job.
Explore Small ProjectsFrom interior and exterior painting to cabinet refinishing, drywall and stucco repair, wood rot and carpentry work, garage floor coatings, and specialty finishes, our team can handle more of your project under one roof. Explore the additional services available for your home or business.
Painting That Elevates Every Space
Interior and exterior painting, stucco repair, and wood and siding repair for Eagle Harbor, Pace Island, Fleming Island Plantation and surrounding Clay County communities.
A New Leaf Painting Contractors provides interior painting, exterior painting, stucco repair, and wood and siding repair in Fleming Island, Florida, along with cabinet refinishing, drywall repair and pressure washing. Our licensed and insured crews serve Eagle Harbor, Pace Island, Fleming Island Plantation and nearby Clay County communities. Every project starts with an evaluation of the actual surface condition rather than a standard specification.
Communities We Serve
Fleming Island
Nearby Clay County
Serving Fleming Island, FL 32003 and surrounding Clay County communities.
Fleming Island homes deal with Florida heat, humidity, heavy rain, UV exposure and shaded elevations. Waterfront and heavily shaded properties may carry additional exposure considerations — but the substrate, the existing coating and the observed condition are what determine the preparation and coating system.
The neighborhood name does not determine the coating system — the existing surface does.
We work regularly in HOA-governed Fleming Island communities, and Eagle Harbor alone contains multiple associations with their own requirements. We document the proposed manufacturer, color, sheen and painted surfaces so homeowners can prepare an architectural review submission. Homeowners and their associations confirm the current approval requirements, since those can change.
Our exterior painting work begins with evaluating what is actually on the house. Depending on the condition, that can include pressure washing, scraping and sanding, caulking at applicable joints, wood and siding repair, and stucco crack preparation before any coating is applied.
Conventional stucco and synthetic stucco or EIFS are different substrates and are not automatically painted the same way. On a prepared conventional stucco or masonry exterior, a high-build masonry coating such as Sherwin-Williams® Loxon® XP may be appropriate — but product selection follows the substrate, the existing coating and the observed condition rather than a single specification applied to every home.
On fiber-cement siding, we evaluate damaged boards, exposed fasteners, failed coatings, and gaps at appropriate transitions before preparing and repainting. Paint does not replace required repairs, flashing, drainage or a sound substrate.
Our interior painting covers walls, ceilings, trim, doors, bedrooms, kitchens, stairwells and full interiors, with floors and furniture protected before work begins.
We repair drywall imperfections, match texture where needed, and select interior products for durability, washability and finished appearance — including more scuff-resistant finishes on high-traffic walls and durable enamels for cabinet refinishing. The written estimate identifies the surfaces, preparation and products included.
Painting costs depend on home size, surface condition, height, access, drywall or wood repairs, fiber-cement siding condition, stucco repairs, caulking, the coating system and HOA requirements. Exterior projects involving wood repair, siding replacement or extensive preparation cost more than a straightforward repaint — but that work is what the coating is protecting.
For a planning range based on your specific home, try our painting cost estimator, or see our detailed guides to interior painting costs and exterior painting costs.
At A New Leaf Painting Contractors, we provide professional residential painting services designed to protect, restore, and enhance homes throughout Fleming Island, FL. Since 2010, our licensed and insured painters have helped homeowners transform everything from single-room interiors to complete exterior repainting projects using premium Sherwin-Williams® and Benjamin Moore® paint systems. Our services include interior painting, exterior painting, cabinet painting, drywall repair, stucco repair, wood rot repair, wallpaper removal, garage floor coatings, and professional color consultations. Whether your home is located in Eagle Harbor, Pace Island, Fleming Island Plantation, Hibernia, Fleming Grove, or along Doctors Lake, every project is customized to your home’s architecture, building materials, HOA requirements, and long-term maintenance needs.
Unlike many Northeast Florida communities, Fleming Island benefits from being inland, reducing the effects of salt air while still facing Florida’s intense heat, humidity, UV exposure, heavy rainfall, and frequent afternoon storms. These conditions make proper surface preparation, premium coating systems, and routine maintenance essential for maximizing the life of your paint. Every project begins with our meticulous Prep-to-Perfection™ Process, including pressure washing, repairs, sanding, scraping, caulking, and priming before two finish coats are applied. This proven approach delivers beautiful, durable results while helping prevent premature peeling, blistering, mildew growth, fading, and moisture-related paint failure.
Because we believe informed homeowners make better long-term decisions, we’ve created several educational resources specifically for Fleming Island homeowners planning future painting projects:
Helpful Resources for Fleming Island Homeowners
How Often Should You Paint a House in Fleming Island, FL?
Learn realistic repainting timelines for stucco, James Hardie® siding, wood, and other exterior materials while understanding the warning signs that indicate it’s time to repaint before costly repairs become necessary.
Exterior House Painting in Fleming Island, FL: The Complete Homeowner’s Guide
Discover our professional exterior painting process, proper surface preparation, common paint failures, product recommendations, maintenance schedules, and Florida-specific best practices for protecting your home’s exterior.
Compare premium Sherwin-Williams® and Benjamin Moore® exterior paint systems engineered to withstand Florida’s harsh UV exposure, humidity, rain, and mildew while maximizing durability and long-term performance.
Whether you’re repainting a newer home, maintaining mature stucco, protecting James Hardie® siding, repairing wood rot, or planning a complete interior or exterior transformation, our goal is to provide both exceptional craftsmanship and trusted homeowner education. From your initial estimate through the final walkthrough, our experienced team delivers the professionalism, communication, and attention to detail that have made A New Leaf Painting Contractors one of Northeast Florida’s most-reviewed painting companies with more than 700+ reviews. We don’t simply paint homes—we help Fleming Island homeowners protect one of their largest investments with beautiful, durable finishes built to last for years to come.
Our painters in Fleming Island, FL take pride in delivering quality work and outstanding results for every home and business. From start to finish, we focus on clear communication, respect for your property, and craftsmanship that lasts. Whether you’re refreshing your walls or protecting your home’s exterior, our team ensures a pleasant and professional experience.
When quality, reliability, and professionalism matter, A New Leaf Painting is the local painting contractor homeowners trust most.
A New Leaf Painting Contractors is a trusted Jacksonville painting company serving homeowners and businesses throughout Jacksonville and Northeast Florida. Since 2010, our Jacksonville house painters have completed more than 5,000 painting projects and earned 700+ reviews.
Those reviews consistently reflect what matters most to our customers: thorough preparation, respect for the property, clear communication, clean job sites, and quality workmanship from start to finish. Our reputation has been built one project at a time by delivering a professional experience homeowners and businesses can feel confident recommending.
Homeowners across Fleming Island, FL count on A New Leaf Painting for professional painting services that combine precision, reliability, and care. Our experienced painters deliver outstanding results with premium materials, clear communication, and a commitment to complete satisfaction on every project.
A dedicated point of contact, straightforward scheduling, and updates you can count on from start to finish.
Premium Sherwin Williams and Benjamin Moore finishes applied with proven techniques and backed by strong warranties.
Itemized proposals, clear scope, and on time delivery. We show up when we say we will and stick to the estimate.
Background checked professionals who protect surfaces, keep job sites tidy, and leave your space clean every day.
Real Projects Near You!
Exterior House Painting in Eagle Harbor, Fleming Island, FLSee the full project






See all our workReal homeowners, in their own homes, in their own words.
Fleming Island
Interior Painting · Fleming Island, FL
Every caption is the crew's own note on where the job was. More from Clay County on the service areas page.

Inspired by what you see?
From interiors and exteriors to cabinets and concrete coatings, our portfolio showcases the quality and care we bring to every job. Now it’s your turn. Whether you’re ready for a refresh or a complete transformation, our team is here to deliver results you’ll be proud of.
700+ Reviews
MORE THAN JUST A FRESH COAT
Scuffs, dated colors, and faded exterior paint can make a home look tired. We help you choose finishes suited to busy rooms indoors and sun and weather exposure outdoors.
Fresh paint can make old repairs stand out. We patch damaged areas, match the surrounding texture where needed, then sand and prime the repairs for a more even finish.
Once a leak or moisture issue is resolved, we prepare the affected surface and use a stain-blocking primer where needed. Outdoors, we clean mildew, algae, chalk, and salt residue before painting.
We check where the old paint is failing, scrape away loose paint, smooth rough edges, and prime exposed areas as needed. If moisture appears to be contributing, we point it out before repainting.
We assess cracked stucco and open joints around windows and doors, then explain which repairs are included. Recurring cracks or signs of water intrusion may need further evaluation before painting.
Soft fascia, deteriorated siding, and damaged trim need attention before they’re painted. We identify what needs repair or replacement and spell it out in your estimate.
We protect your home while we work. We cover floors, furniture, and nearby exterior surfaces as needed, protect landscaping where appropriate, and keep work areas organized.
What to expect
What We Evaluate Before Painting
The neighborhood name does not determine the coating system, the existing surface does. These are common conditions we evaluate so repairs and preparation can be written into the estimate before work begins.
Sun and weather can leave a powdery residue on an aging coating. Painting over that unstable surface can weaken adhesion, so the exterior must be cleaned and evaluated before primer, sealer or finish paint is selected.
Shaded walls and areas with slower drying may develop organic growth. Cleaning is only the first step; active leaks, drainage defects or persistent moisture should be corrected rather than hidden beneath a new coating.
A stucco crack and a failed sealant joint are different conditions and should not automatically receive the same treatment. We identify where patching, texture matching or sealant replacement belongs before specifying the coating.
Fascia, soffits, door frames and decorative trim should be firm and paint-ready. Soft or deteriorated material needs repair or replacement; paint cannot restore structural integrity to damaged wood.
Damaged boards, exposed fasteners, failed coatings and gaps at appropriate transitions require different corrections. We evaluate the existing installation instead of indiscriminately caulking every siding joint.
One side of a home may chalk and fade while another stays damp and develops mildew. Preparation is adjusted to the conditions found on each elevation rather than assuming the entire exterior has weathered uniformly.
Eagle Harbor and other Fleming Island associations may require architectural review. Homeowners should confirm the current approval process, and we can document proposed manufacturers, colors, sheens and painted surfaces for the submission.
Nail pops, prior patches, scuffs and sheen changes become more visible under side lighting. Our interior painting process defines repairs, protection and the appropriate washable finish before work starts.
We evaluate the property before quoting, so the preparation, repairs and coating system in your estimate are the ones your home actually needs.
The A New Leaf Standard
A fresh coat of paint is easy to promise. What you live with afterward is the difference — careful preparation, quality materials, clean lines, protected surfaces, clear communication, and a job finished with care.
Since 2010, we’ve brought that same standard of care to every project — from a single room or cabinet refinishing project to complete exteriors, commercial spaces, and concrete coatings.
Stucco cracks, wood rot, drywall damage, and other surface problems are addressed before the finish coat goes on.
Your crew stays focused on your project instead of bouncing between multiple jobs and leaving you waiting.
Floors, furniture, landscaping, and surrounding surfaces are carefully protected while we work, with clean job sites maintained throughout the project.
Our preparation and coating systems are selected around the heat, humidity, moisture, stucco, and exterior conditions common throughout Northeast Florida.

Experience the difference of working with a team dedicated to your home’s beauty and long-term protection.
Fleming Island painting costs
Plan your Fleming Island painting project with the pricing ranges below. Your final price depends on the surfaces included, their condition, preparation, repairs, and access. During your free on-site estimate, we review the details with you and provide a clear written scope and project price before work begins.

Paints & Coatings
We use Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore products, chosen for the surface, the room and the Florida conditions it faces. The exact products for your project are listed in your written estimate.
Coatings for stucco, siding and trim that help resist sun, humidity, rain and mildew.
Washable finishes for kitchens, baths and high-traffic rooms, softer sheens for bedrooms.
Stain-blocking, bonding and masonry primers so the topcoat lasts.
Project Spotlights
Project SpotlightExterior House Painting in Eagle Harbor, Fleming Island, FLEagle Harbor, Fleming Island, FL 32003Exterior Painting · Stucco RepairSee the full project
Project SpotlightFleming Island Residential Exterior RepaintFleming Island, Orange Park, FL 32003Exterior Painting · Carpentry & Wood Rot Repair · Power WashingSee the full project
Project SpotlightEagle Harbor Exterior Painting ProjectFleming Island, FL 32003Exterior Painting · Stucco Repair · Power WashingSee the full projectHomeowner Resources · Northeast Florida
Straight answers to the cost, preparation, product, repair, and color questions that come up on real painting projects across Northeast Florida, so you know what matters before the work begins.
What to ask before you hire, from licensing and insurance to the warranty that stands behind the work.
Understand color requirements, approval considerations, and the information you may need for an HOA or ARB submission.
Why exterior paint fails in Florida, what proper preparation prevents, and how to choose a coating that holds up.
Understand what drives painting costs, where the money goes, and why two estimates for the same home can differ.
Practical guidance on colors, sheens, preparation, repairs, and finishes that stand up to everyday living.
Learn what cracks, moisture, failed caulking, and deteriorated wood can mean before exterior painting begins.
HOAs and communities
Black Creek, Stone Creek, Pine Lake
Manager:Paraclete Services / BCM. Phone:(904) 278-0616. Stone Creek:RealManage (866) 473-2573. Verified April 2026
Margarets Walk, Pace Island
Managers:May Management, Vesta
Clay County · Established community
Manager:Verify with HOA office
Clay County · Master-planned
Manager:Verify with HOA office
Clay County · Established community
Manager:Verify with HOA office
Clay County · Established community
Manager:Verify with HOA office
Clay County · Established community
Manager:Verify with HOA office
Clay County · Established community
Manager:Verify with HOA office
Clay County · Master-planned
Manager:Verify with HOA office
Our work, mapped
14 of our projects mapped in Fleming Island
Nearby
Ready to Transform Your Space?
Our professional painting contractors in Fleming Island, FL are ready to bring your vision to life with high-quality interior and exterior painting services. From drywall repairs to complete makeovers, we deliver quality work, friendly service, and lasting results—on time and within budget.
700+ Reviews

Request a callback
Tell us about the job and we call back to book a walkthrough. No obligation.


Contact us to set up a free, no-obligation estimate at a time that works best for you.
We handle pressure washing, scraping, sanding, repairs, priming, and caulking to ensure a smooth surface and long-lasting finish.
Our skilled, background-checked craftsmen complete the work with precision, using premium products and proven techniques.
Before we finish, we walk through the project with you to ensure every detail meets expectations. Plus, your job is backed by our workmanship warranty!
We paint homes in neighborhoods such as Eagle Harbor, Pace Island, Fleming Island Plantation, Hibernia Plantation, Greyhawk, Two Creeks, Thrasher Landing, Spencer’s Crossing, and along Doctors Lake and the riverfront. We also work in nearby Clay County communities, including Orange Park, Green Cove Springs, Middleburg and Magnolia Point.
Yes. We paint interiors and exteriors, including the stucco, fiber-cement siding and wood trim found on many homes in the area, and we also offer cabinet painting. Your written estimate spells out the surfaces, preparation, repairs and products included before any work begins.
Not automatically. Fleming Island has both synthetic stucco (EIFS) and conventional cement stucco homes, and they are different substrates, so we identify the wall finish and its existing coating before choosing the preparation, primer or sealer, and finish. Two documented Eagle Harbor projects, one of each type, ended up with different preparation and coating systems.
Yes, as part of a full exterior painting project. Soft fascia, soffits, door frames and trim are repaired or replaced, and a stucco crack is evaluated separately from a failed sealant joint, since the two should not automatically get the same treatment. Painting over rotten wood is not recommended, since paint cannot restore damaged material.
Yes. We can help with color selection and provide the product names, color codes and sheen information that many architectural review submissions ask for. Requirements vary, and Eagle Harbor alone includes multiple associations with their own requirements, so confirm the current approval process with your association before colors are finalized.
Partly. Being inland reduces the effects of salt air, but strong sun, humidity, heavy rain and frequent afternoon storms still break down coatings. Waterfront and heavily shaded properties may carry added exposure considerations, and one side of a house can fade while another stays damp and grows mildew, so preparation is adjusted to each elevation.
Published starting ranges for exterior painting are $3,500–$7,200+ for a 1,500–2,000 sq. ft. home and $5,500–$11,495+ for 2,500–3,000 sq. ft., while interior walls and trim on a 2,500–2,800 sq. ft. home run $8,000–$13,500. Wood repair, siding work or extensive preparation adds to the price. Final pricing comes from a written estimate after we see the home.
Yes. Every estimate is free and comes in writing, outlining the scope, repairs and products before work begins. When comparing bids, keep in mind that a lower estimate may simply include less preparation, fewer repairs, different products, or less project management.
A New Leaf Painting Contractors provides professional interior and exterior painting services in Fleming Island and across Clay County, along with cabinet painting, drywall repair, stucco repair, wood rot repair, wallpaper removal, and garage floor coatings. The company has served Jacksonville and Northeast Florida since 2010 and has hundreds of five-star reviews.
A New Leaf Painting Contractors is a long-established Northeast Florida painting company serving residential and commercial clients in Fleming Island and throughout Clay County. Since 2010, the company has completed thousands of projects and offers interior painting, exterior painting, cabinet refinishing, surface repairs, and related painting services.
A New Leaf Painting Contractors serves Fleming Island and surrounding Clay County communities with professional painting and repair services. The company is insured, Google Verified, BBB A+ Rated, and known for written scopes, careful preparation, property protection, clear communication, and workmanship warranties.
A New Leaf Painting Contractors provides experienced painting services in Fleming Island and throughout Clay County, including interior and exterior painting, drywall and stucco repair, wood rot and carpentry repairs, cabinet refinishing, and specialty coatings. The company has served Northeast Florida homeowners and businesses since 2010 and uses professional-grade Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore coating systems.