Skip to content
Book ahead: Schedule your Interior or Exterior Painting for Dec–Feb and lock in 15% off--d --h --m --s
A New Leaf Painting Contractors home
From the blog

HOA Paint Fines vs. Professional Painting Jacksonville

HOA paint fines in Jacksonville can hit $100/day. See the real 10-year math on cheap painters vs. premium exterior painting from a 25-year Florida contractor.

By Thomas Drake, owner7 min read

The Real Math, by the Numbers

In this article
  1. What HOA Paint Fines Can Cost in Jacksonville, FL
  2. The Real Math: Cheap Paint Job vs. Doing It Right
  3. Why Cheap Paint Can Fail in 3 Years in Florida
  4. A Marsh Landing Example: Paying for the Same Job Twice
  5. Already Received an HOA Paint Violation Letter? Do This First.
  6. What Your HOA Paint Submission Should Include
  7. Questions to Ask Before Hiring an HOA Exterior Painter
  8. Jacksonville HOA paint questions, answered honestly
  9. More HOA and exterior painting resources
Professional HOA paint approval submission packet for Julington Creek Plantation and Nocatee homeowners by A New Leaf Painting.
Professional HOA paint approval submission packet for Julington Creek Plantation and Nocatee homeowners by A New Leaf Painting.

In Florida, an HOA can generally fine you up to $100 per violation for painting without approval, and a continuing violation can be fined daily, usually up to $1,000 in total unless your community's documents allow more. On top of the fine, the HOA can usually make you repaint in an approved color at your own cost. That's why the cheapest painting quote can turn into the most expensive one: you pay for the job twice.

I'm Thomas Drake, and I've been painting since 1988. As exterior painting contractors in Jacksonville FL since 2010, we've seen this play out more often than you'd think. A homeowner takes the lowest of three quotes, the painter picks a color off the shelf without an ARB approval, and a violation letter shows up a few weeks after the crew leaves. Here's how the math works and how to avoid it.

What HOA Paint Fines Can Cost in Jacksonville, FL

Florida's HOA law (Section 720.305 of the Florida Statutes) sets the general rules. A fine requires notice and a chance at a hearing. The default limits are $100 per violation and $1,000 in total for a continuing violation, but your community's recorded covenants can set a higher total. A fine under $1,000 generally can't become a lien on your home. Larger unpaid fines, or fines combined with unpaid assessments, can lead to one.

Fine schedules, cure periods and approval rules vary a lot between communities, even between sub-associations in the same development. Before painting, pull your own covenants and ARB guidelines and ask your management company how enforcement works.

The fine is usually the smaller cost. The bigger one is the forced repaint. And a lien shows up when you sell or refinance, and has to be cleared, often with interest and the HOA's attorney fees, before closing.

The Real Math: Cheap Paint Job vs. Doing It Right

Picture the same stucco home in an HOA in Ponte Vedra Beach, Nocatee, Fleming Island or Julington Creek, priced three ways. Spread over how long each job typically lasts, here's what you pay per year for a roughly 2,200 square foot exterior:

OptionInitial CostExpected LifeCost Per Year
Budget Paint Job$4,4003 years$1,467/year
Mid-Grade Paint Job$6,2006 years$1,033/year
Premium Paint System$8,40010 years$840/year

Swipe to see the whole table

These are example figures, and your written estimate gives the real number for your home. But the pattern holds: the budget job costs less on day one and more per year. And that's before any HOA trouble. If the cheap job also went on in an unapproved color, add the fines and a second full repaint by another contractor, because the first painter rarely comes back to redo it.

For what an exterior repaint costs here, see our exterior painting cost guide for Jacksonville, FL.

Why Cheap Paint Can Fail in 3 Years in Florida

Budget and contractor-grade exterior paints aren't made for our mix of strong sun, humidity, salt air and afternoon storms. Add one coat instead of two, skipped primer on glossy trim and a quick rinse instead of real prep, and we see them fading on south and west walls, growing mildew on north walls and peeling on trim within a few years. It's worse near the coast.

Premium lines such as Sherwin-Williams Emerald and Benjamin Moore Aura are made to hold color and resist mildew longer in conditions like ours. With proper prep, they typically last 8 to 12 years here. Over their life they usually cost less per year than the budget option, as the table shows.

A Marsh Landing Example: Paying for the Same Job Twice

One homeowner in Marsh Landing hired a low-priced, uninsured painter who suggested a soft sage green that wasn't on the community's approved palette. Nobody submitted an ARB application. A few weeks after the job, the HOA sent a violation letter ordering a repaint in an approved color, with fines starting after the cure period. The original painter walked away, so the homeowner paid a second contractor to repaint the whole house, plus the fines and submission fees. The total came to far more than doing it right the first time would have cost.

The bargain quote assumed nobody would notice. In an HOA, somebody always does.

Already Received an HOA Paint Violation Letter? Do This First.

  1. Don't ignore it

    Silence is the fastest way to more fines and a possible lien.

  2. Read the deadline

    The letter states the issue, the cure period and what happens if it isn't fixed.

  3. Get the approved palette in writing

    Ask the management company to email it.

  4. Ask about fines and extensions

    Find out whether fines have started, and ask for more time if you're acting in good faith. Many ARBs will work with you.

  5. Get a written repaint scope

    Have a painter inspect and price the corrective work.

  6. Submit a corrected ARB application before repainting

    Don't paint the wrong color twice. Save every approval email with your closing documents.

If you'd like a free walk-through, contact us with a copy of the letter and we'll help you map the path forward. You can also find your community's management contact in our HOA Directory.

What Your HOA Paint Submission Should Include

Most rejected applications come back because the technical fields are missing or wrong. A complete ARB packet usually includes:

  • Your name, address and community or sub-association
  • Existing colors and the proposed body, trim and door colors
  • Paint manufacturer, product line, color names and color codes
  • Sheen for each surface
  • LRV (light reflectance value) when your HOA asks for it
  • Swatches or drawdowns and photos of the home
  • Scope of work, estimated dates and the contractor's insurance information

With every estimate, we provide the product, color, code, sheen, LRV, prep scope and our $3 million insurance certificate your application needs. You stay the submitter, because the HOA's relationship is with you, and you wait for written approval before work starts. Verbal approval doesn't count. Our HOA Color Guide shows approved palettes for many Jacksonville communities.

Questions to Ask Before Hiring an HOA Exterior Painter

  • Have you painted in HOA communities like mine? Ask for local references.
  • Will you put the product line, color names, codes and sheens in writing? "Premium paint" is not a specification.
  • Do you carry liability insurance and workers' compensation? Have the certificates sent to you by the insurer. Florida has no statewide painting license, so also check any county or city license that applies.
  • What does the prep include? Washing, scraping, sanding, caulking, primer and wood rot repair should be itemized.
  • How many coats, and of what? Two coats on body and trim, brand and line in writing.
  • What is your written warranty? Get both the manufacturer's and the workmanship terms in the contract.

Then inspect during the job, not after. Check that the prep is being done, that two coats actually go on and that the colors on the wall match your approved application. Photos of the prep stage help.

Jacksonville HOA paint questions, answered honestly

Under Florida law, generally up to $100 per violation, with daily fines for a continuing violation capped at $1,000 in total unless your community's documents allow more. Check your own covenants, and talk to your HOA or an attorney with specific questions.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. HOA rules, fines and enforcement depend on your community's governing documents and Florida law, so check your covenants and talk to a Florida attorney about your situation.

For more help, see our interior painting, exterior painting and stucco repair services, and our interior painting resource center and exterior painting resource center. A New Leaf Painting Contractors has completed more than 5,000 projects in Northeast Florida and has 700+ reviews. Your free estimate includes the paint and color details your ARB application needs, and our work is backed by our Iron-Clad Guarantee.

See Our Work

Free estimate

Get a free painting estimate

Pick a time online, or tell us about the job and someone from the crew calls back to book a walkthrough.

See Our Work
  • Fast scheduling available
  • 904-615-6599
  • Office Mon to Sun, 7am to 7pm
  • Licensed & insured, $3M+ coverage

Request a callback

Get Your Free Painting Estimate Today

Free, no-obligation estimate. We call to book a walkthrough.